CVE-2016-10011
Medium · 6.2CVSS
6.2
EPSS
1.1%
Published
Jan 5, 2017
CISA due date
—
Cloudanix analysis
A local user on an affected system could potentially read private SSH keys because of a memory handling mistake in the SSH server software.
- Exploitation
- Local Privilege
- Attacker needs
- Local User
- Complexity
- Low
- Impact
- Data Exposure
- Component
- Network Service
- Class
- Information Disclosure
- Remediation
- Upgrade
- Effort
- Medium
- Patch risk
- Low
What it actually does
Local users with access to a privilege-separated sshd child process can obtain sensitive private-key material due to improper handling of realloc effects on buffer contents in authfile.c.
Why it matters to the business
Exposure of SSH private keys can enable lateral movement or persistent unauthorized access across systems, increasing breach risk especially in environments with many OpenSSH deployments.
How an attack unfolds
An attacker with local access to a privilege-separated sshd child process triggers the realloc flaw in authfile.c to read residual sensitive buffer contents containing private key data.
How to fix it
Upgrade OpenSSH to version 7.4 or later. For openbsd/src apply commit ac8147a06ed2e2403fb6b9a0c03e618a9333c0e9; for regclient (Chainguard) and regclient (Wolfi) upgrade to 0.5.7-r1 or newer.
How to confirm the fix worked
Confirm sshd version is 7.4 or higher and verify the authfile.c realloc handling patch is present via source inspection or package metadata.
Typical attack path
- Obtain local non-privileged access on a host running vulnerable OpenSSH sshd
- Interact with or influence the privilege-separated child process handling authentication files
- Trigger realloc operations that leave private key material readable in memory buffers
- Extract and exfiltrate the leaked private key data for later use
How to detect it
Review sshd process memory dumps or core files from privilege-separated children for unexpected private key artifacts; examine local access logs around sshd child processes for unusual activity.
What your security team should do
- Prioritize patching all OpenSSH instances to 7.4+ given the key disclosure risk
- Audit systems for exposed private keys that may have been leaked before patching
- Enforce least-privilege access and monitor for anomalous local process interactions with sshd
The record
authfile.c in sshd in OpenSSH before 7.4 does not properly consider the effects of realloc on buffer contents, which might allow local users to obtain sensitive private-key information by leveraging access to a privilege-separated child process.
Affected packages
| Ecosystem | Package | Introduced | Fixed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alpine:v3.10 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.11 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.12 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.13 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.14 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.15 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.16 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.17 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.18 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.19 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.2 | openssh | 0 | 6.8_p1-r9 |
| Alpine:v3.20 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.21 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.22 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.3 | openssh | 0 | 7.2_p2-r3 |
| Alpine:v3.4 | openssh | 0 | 7.2_p2-r4 |
| Alpine:v3.5 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.6 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.7 | openssh | 0 | 7.5_p1-r8 |
| Alpine:v3.8 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Alpine:v3.9 | openssh | 0 | 7.4_p1-r0 |
| Debian:10 | openssh | 0 | 1:7.4p1-1 |
| Debian:11 | openssh | 0 | 1:7.4p1-1 |
| Debian:12 | openssh | 0 | 1:7.4p1-1 |
| Debian:13 | openssh | 0 | 1:7.4p1-1 |
| Debian:14 | openssh | 0 | 1:7.4p1-1 |
| Debian:8 | openssh | 0 | 1:6.7p1-5+deb8u6 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::client | openssh | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::client | openssh-askpass | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::client | openssh-cavs | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::client | openssh-clients | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::client | openssh-debuginfo | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::client | openssh-keycat | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::client | openssh-ldap | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::client | openssh-server | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::client | openssh-server-sysvinit | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::client | pam_ssh_agent_auth | 0 | 0:0.10.3-1.11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::computenode | openssh | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::computenode | openssh-askpass | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::computenode | openssh-cavs | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::computenode | openssh-clients | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::computenode | openssh-debuginfo | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::computenode | openssh-keycat | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::computenode | openssh-ldap | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::computenode | openssh-server | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::computenode | openssh-server-sysvinit | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::computenode | pam_ssh_agent_auth | 0 | 0:0.10.3-1.11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::server | openssh | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::server | openssh-askpass | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::server | openssh-cavs | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::server | openssh-clients | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::server | openssh-debuginfo | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::server | openssh-keycat | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::server | openssh-ldap | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::server | openssh-server | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::server | openssh-server-sysvinit | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::server | pam_ssh_agent_auth | 0 | 0:0.10.3-1.11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::workstation | openssh | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::workstation | openssh-askpass | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::workstation | openssh-cavs | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::workstation | openssh-clients | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::workstation | openssh-debuginfo | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::workstation | openssh-keycat | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::workstation | openssh-ldap | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::workstation | openssh-server | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::workstation | openssh-server-sysvinit | 0 | 0:7.4p1-11.el7 |
| Red Hat:enterprise_linux:7::workstation | pam_ssh_agent_auth | 0 | 0:0.10.3-1.11.el7 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Desktop 12 SP1 | openssh | 0 | 6.6p1-54.7.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Desktop 12 SP1 | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 6.6p1-54.7.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Desktop 12 SP2 | openssh | 0 | 7.2p2-66.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Desktop 12 SP2 | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 7.2p2-66.3 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Point of Sale 11 SP3 | openssh | 0 | 6.2p2-0.40.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Point of Sale 11 SP3 | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 6.2p2-0.40.3 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server 11 SP3-LTSS | openssh | 0 | 6.2p2-0.40.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server 11 SP3-LTSS | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 6.2p2-0.40.3 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server 11 SP3-TERADATA | openssh | 0 | 6.2p2-0.40.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server 11 SP3-TERADATA | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 6.2p2-0.40.3 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server 11 SP4 | openssh | 0 | 6.6p1-35.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server 11 SP4 | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 6.6p1-35.4 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server 11-SECURITY | openssh-openssl1 | 0 | 6.6p1-18.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server 12 SP1 | openssh | 0 | 6.6p1-54.7.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server 12 SP1 | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 6.6p1-54.7.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server 12 SP2 | openssh | 0 | 7.2p2-66.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server 12 SP2 | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 7.2p2-66.3 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server 12-LTSS | openssh | 0 | 6.6p1-54.7.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server 12-LTSS | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 6.6p1-54.7.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server for Raspberry Pi 12 SP2 | openssh | 0 | 7.2p2-66.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server for Raspberry Pi 12 SP2 | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 7.2p2-66.3 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server for SAP Applications 11 SP4 | openssh | 0 | 6.6p1-35.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server for SAP Applications 11 SP4 | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 6.6p1-35.4 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server for SAP Applications 12 | openssh | 0 | 6.6p1-54.7.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server for SAP Applications 12 | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 6.6p1-54.7.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server for SAP Applications 12 SP1 | openssh | 0 | 6.6p1-54.7.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server for SAP Applications 12 SP1 | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 6.6p1-54.7.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server for SAP Applications 12 SP2 | openssh | 0 | 7.2p2-66.1 |
| SUSE:Linux Enterprise Server for SAP Applications 12 SP2 | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 7.2p2-66.3 |
| SUSE:Manager 2.1 | openssh | 0 | 6.2p2-0.40.1 |
| SUSE:Manager 2.1 | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 6.2p2-0.40.3 |
| SUSE:Manager Proxy 2.1 | openssh | 0 | 6.2p2-0.40.1 |
| SUSE:Manager Proxy 2.1 | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 6.2p2-0.40.3 |
| SUSE:OpenStack Cloud 5 | openssh | 0 | 6.2p2-0.40.1 |
| SUSE:OpenStack Cloud 5 | openssh-askpass-gnome | 0 | 6.2p2-0.40.3 |
| Ubuntu:14.04:LTS | openssh | 0 | 1:6.6p1-2ubuntu2.10 |
| Ubuntu:16.04:LTS | openssh | 0 | 1:7.2p2-4ubuntu2.4 |
| openSUSE:Tumbleweed | openssh | 0 | 8.4p1-7.4 |
Related vulnerabilities
- CVE-2019-6109 An issue was discovered in OpenSSH 7.9. Also affects openssh
- CVE-2017-15906 The process_open function in sftp-server.c in OpenSSH before 7.6 does not properly… Also affects openssh
- CVE-2016-10012 The shared memory manager (associated with pre-authentication compression) in sshd in… Also affects openssh
- CVE-2016-10009 Untrusted search path vulnerability in ssh-agent.c in ssh-agent in OpenSSH before 7.4… Also affects openssh
- CVE-2021-41617 sshd in OpenSSH 6.2 through 8.x before 8.8, when certain non-default configurations are… Also affects openssh
- CVE-2023-51385 In ssh in OpenSSH before 9.6, OS command injection might occur if a user name or host… Also affects openssh
- CVE-2023-51384 In ssh-agent in OpenSSH before 9.6, certain destination constraints can be incompletely… Also affects openssh
- CVE-2023-48795 The SSH transport protocol with certain OpenSSH extensions, found in OpenSSH before 9.6… Also affects openssh